Home /Entertainment / Hi8 vs MiniDV

Hi8 vs MiniDV

Share
By Dillon Wallace

The video tape has an illustrious history. From the Betamax to VHS to VHS-C, to Hi8 to MiniDV and more. And all throughout this videolution, the video tape just kept getting smaller and better.


But with so many formats introduced to the market over the decades, it’s hard to know the differences between them. What tapes were what and when were they released? Which had better features? Which were backwards compatible? You name it.


So let’s hit play and shed a little bit of light on these questions as we uncover the differences between two out of the many video tape formats: Hi8 and MiniDV.

Hi8

Just before the 90s hit, 8mm tape tried to make a comeback of sorts. Video8 analog video tapes had been released, followed shortly after by the introduction of its improved successor, the Hi8, in 1989. These tapes were still analog video and analog audio but with the option for digital audio. It was Sony’s answer to combat the Super-VHS format, and Hi8 would last until Sony’s inevitable upgrade, the Digital8, released in 1999. This new Digital8 format did everything its name suggested, recorded digital video and audio, plus it had reverse compatibility, being able to play older 8mm (Video8) and Hi8 tapes. The same, however, could not be said for Hi8, which could only play Hi8 tapes and Video8 tapes – sorry, no Digital8.


Hi8 tapes were frequently used by amateur videographers and in some minor television productions, thanks to its lightweight and portability. Hi8 featured:

  • Analog AFM audio & PCM audio recording (in some higher end models only)
  • 400-line video luminance resolution capability
  • Recording lengths of 30, 60 and 120 minutes

Although Hi8 took a backseat to Digital8, its camcorder wasn’t actually discontinued until 2007 – just shy of 20 years after its initial release. And the tapes themselves, they lasted a few years longer finally bidding adieu in 2012.


MiniDV

By the time the late 90s rolled around, the VHS (and VHS-C) had been king of the home video market for more than a decade. Video8 and Hi8 had helped make the filming industry more portable, but a new challenger would appear just before the millennium, the MiniDV. This new “mini” 6mm tape was tinier than ever, making it ridiculously portable. It was also an innovation, being the first digital camcorder format released, followed shortly by the Digital8 format – HI8s successor and it’s biggest competitor.

MiniDV featured:

  • PCM audio recording
  • 500-line video resolution capability
  • 640x480 still-picture resolution
  • IEEE 1394Firewire, i-Link computer interface
  • Up to 90 minutes record time in LP mode

Manufactures saw the promise in MiniDV when it was released, which is why several major companies, including Canon, Sony, JVC, Panasonic and Sharp all hopped on the little tape’s bandwagon. And because Digital8 was only manufactured by Sony, the MiniDV eventually won that format war heading into the 2000s.


But just because these former rivals have long ended their format war, it doesn’t mean they’re dead. If you’ve got any old Video8, Hi8, Digital8 or MiniDVs laying around the house – say in a closet or attic, then you’re in luck. Those memories can be digitized and we can help! So, forget about the format feud, it’s time to save your memories while there’s still time. Chances are they’re brimming with magnificent 90s and turn-of-the-century nostalgia. 
Continue Reading
Exploring Your Hometown
Exploring Your Hometown
How to Store Film Reels
How to Store Film Reels
Hi8 Tape Features
Hi8 Tape Features
Kodak Throwback
KODAK Digitizing Box. Shop Now>
KODAK Folding 'Brownie' Six-20
Kodachrome Photo Slides
3 Ways to Preserve your Memories
KODAK Digitizing Box. Shop Now>
Get more Vitamin D
Play Brain Games
Plan a Perfect Family Weekend
Preserve your Recorded Memories. Shop Now>
Create a Highlight Reel
Enjoy a Family Watch Party
Advertisement